PhysioUpdate 12th July 2022

Set watertight NHS contracts to stop for-profit providers cutting corners on quality, says academic

A study published today (30 June) in the journal Lancet Public Health claims to have found a link between an increase in the privatisation of health services in England in recent years and higher rates of treatable mortality – deaths considered to be avoidable with the delivery of timely and effective health care.

The authors suggest this indicates that the quality of healthcare has declined over the period covered by the study (2013 to 2020).

In a Comment article linked to the study, Andrew Street of the London School of Economics and Political Science, who was not involved in the paper, said: ‘Arguments have long raged about what role the private sector should play in the United Kingdom’s health system, where provision is dominated by the NHS.’

The findings are based on money regional health boards spent on outsourcing 2013-2020

Contracts offer the 'only protection'

Professor Street noted: ‘Despite the inability to establish a causal mechanism, the study adds to the evidence base examining the impacts of privatisation on the health system in England.’ And, commenting on the possibility that further privatisation could be in the offing, Professor Street added: ‘For-profit providers may secure greater profit for their shareholders by being innovative and quick to adopt the latest technologies. But a faster route to making profits might be to compromise quality.

‘The only protection against this double-edged sword is via the contract: quality standards must be fully spelt out, there must be careful monitoring of performance, and there must be strict enforcement when standards fall short.’

To see the full version of the Comment, visit:

New data set

The study published in Lancet Public Health is said to represent the first comprehensive assessment of NHS privatisation in England to have been conducted since the 2012 series of reforms encouraged a greater outsourcing of services. Co-author Benjamin Goodair said: ‘The unparalleled data utilised in this study enabled us to conduct the first rigorous analysis of one the most controversial health care reforms in England’s recent history.

‘While some have argued the Health and Social Care Act would improve the performance of health services by increasing competition, our findings add merit to long-standing concerns it could instead lead to cost-cutting and poorer health outcomes.’

The authors, Mr Goodair and Aaron Reeves, both of whom are based at the University of Oxford, analysed a new data set showing how much each regional health board spent on outsourcing from 2013 to 2020. Changes to the quality of health services were determined using a statistical analysis to investigate associations between outsourcing and treatable mortality – a key measure of the effectiveness of timely healthcare interventions.

These results clearly have implications for the NHS privatisation debate, suggesting that increased outsourcing to the private sector could lead to a decline in the quality of care provided to patients [Aaron Reeves]

The analysis suggests overall levels of outsourcing in England increased consistently from 2013, rising from less than 4 per cent to more than 6 per cent of total regional health board spend by 2020. In total, £11.5bn was spent outsourcing health services to the private sector over the period, with the amount varying considerably by individual health boards. The largest increases in outsourcing spend were on business and IT support, with steady increases in spending on healthcare businesses, social work, and transport companies.

The statistical analysis showed that an annual increase in outsource spending of 1 per cent is associated with a rise in treatable mortality of 0.38 per cent (0.29 deaths per 100,000 population) the following year. Based on observed changes in outsourcing spend and treatable deaths for each health board, the analysis shows 557 additional deaths between 2014 and 2020 might be attributed to changes in outsourcing.

More research needed

Co-author Aaron Reeves said: ‘These results clearly have implications for the NHS privatisation debate, suggesting that increased outsourcing to the private sector could lead to a decline in the quality of care provided to patients. While more research is needed to determine the precise causes of the declining quality of healthcare in England, our findings suggest that further increases in NHS privatisation would be a mistake.'

Dr Reeves added: ‘The findings of this research are timely as the way England’s health boards are organised is set to be overhauled. This creates a key moment where the role of the private sector within the NHS must be closely scrutinised.’

The authors acknowledge that their study had some limitations. Major changes to regional health boards since 2013 limited their ability to measure outsourcing before then, or to conduct before-and-after analyses. The findings are not evidence of a causal relationship between outsourcing and mortality rates, so there is a possibility that other factors may also be involved.

The study was funded by The Wellcome Trust.

To see the full version of the paper, visit

Physios urged to help GP practices become Veteran Friendly Accredited on eve of Armed Forces Day
Physiotherapists who act as the first port of call for patients with musculoskeletal (MSK) problems in primary care settings can help to 'make a difference' for veterans of the Armed Forces. That is the message from Dr (Brigadier Retired) Robin Simpson, when he spoke to PhysioUpdate about the important role that first contact practitioners (FCPs) can play in an initiative known as Veteran Friendly GP Practice Accreditation. This nationwide scheme is hosted by the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP).
Speaking on 24 June (the day before Armed Forces Day is celebrated), Dr Simpson said: 'Becoming the veteran clinical lead at your practice is a great opportunity for first contact practitioners (FCPs) to use their skills and knowledge to really make a difference to veteran patients.'
One Armed Forces veteran in two has a long-term illness, disability or infirmity

Read More

Meet Kerry Archer, professional lead for physio at Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust
'Trust your ability': a lesson that Kerry Archer learned at work the day we interviewed her

Read More

Want to receive newsletters?

FREE membership

Join Us

Sign up today for membership and get...

✓ Regular newsletters
✓ Full website access
✓ Sponsor Benefits

We’ll keep you connected so you’ll NEVER MISS AN UPDATE!

Join Here

Previous newsletters

PhysioUpdate Supplier News 4th August 2022
PhysioUpdate 2nd August 2022
PhysioUpdate 1st August 2022
PhysioUpdate 28th July 2022
PhysioUpdate 26th July 2022
PhysioUpdate 21st July 2022
PhysioUpdate 19th July 2022
PhysioUpdate 14th July 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 7th July 2022
PhysioUpdate 5th July 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 30th June 2022
PhysioUpdate 30th June 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 23rd June 2022
PhysioUpdate 21st June 2022
PhysioUpdate 16th June 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 14th June 2022
PhysioUpdate 7th June 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 6th June 2022
PhysioUpdate 1st June 2022
PhysioUpdate 24th May 2022
PhysioUpdate 19th May 2022
PhysioUpdate 17th May 2022
PhysioUpdate 12th May 2022
PhysioUpdate 10th May 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 5th May 2022
PhysioUpdate 3rd May 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 28th April 2022
PhysioUpdate 26th April 2022
PhysioUpdate 19th April 2022
PhysioUpdate 14th April 2022
PhysioUpdate 12th April 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 7th April 2022
PhysioUpdate 5th April 2022
PhysioUpdate 31st March 2022
PhysioUpdate 29th March 2022
PhysioUpdate 22nd March 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 17th March 2022
PhysioUpdate 15th March 2022
PhysioUpdate 8th March 2022
PhysioUpdate 3rd March 2022
PhysioUpdate 1st March 2022
PhysioUpdate 22nd February 2022
PhysioUpdate 17th February 2022
PhysioUpdate 15th February 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 10th February 2022
PhysioUpdate 8th February 2022
PhysioUpdate 3rd February 2022
PhysioUpdate 1st February 2022
PhysioUpdate 25th January 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 20th January 2022
PhysioUpdate 18th January 2022
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 13th January 2022
PhysioUpdate 11th January 2022
PhysioUpdate 28th December 2021
PhysioUpdate 21st December 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 16th December 2021
PhysioUpdate 14th December 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 9th December 2021
PhysioUpdate 7th December 2021
PhysioUpdate 30th November 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 25th November 2021
PhysioUpdate 23rd November 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 18th November 2021
PhysioUpdate 16th November 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 11th November 2021
PhysioUpdate 9th November 2021
PhysioUpdate 2nd November 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 28th October 2021
PhysioUpdate 26th October 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 21st October 2021
PhysioUpdate 19th October 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 14th October 2021
PhysioUpdate 12th October 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 7th October 2021
PhysioUpdate 5th October 2021
PhysioUpdate 28th September 2021
PhysioUpdate 21st September 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 16th September 2021
PhysioUpdate 14th September 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 9th September 2021
PhysioUpdate 7th September 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 2nd September 2021
PhysioUpdate 24th August 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 19th August 2021
PhysioUpdate 17th August 2021
PhysioUpdate 3rd August 2021
PhysioUpdate 27th July 2021
PhysioUpdate 20th July 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 15th July 2021
PhysioUpdate 13th July 2021
PhysioUpdate 6th July 2021
PhysioUpdate 29th June 2021
PhysioUpdate 22nd June 2021
PhysioUpdate Suppliers News 18th June
PhysioUpdate 15th June 2021
PhysioUpdate 8th June 2021
PhysioUpdate 2nd June 2021
PhysioUpdate 4th May 2021
PhysioUpdate 27th April 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 22nd April
PhysioUpdate 6th April 2021
PhysioUpdate 30th March 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 25th March
PhysioUpdate 23rd March 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 18th March 2021
PhysioUpdate 16th March 2021
PhysioUpdate 9th March 2021
PhysioUpdate 2nd March 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 25th February
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 18th February
PhysioUpdate 16th February 2021
PhysioUpdate 2nd February 2021
PhysioUpdate Supplier News 21st January
PhysioUpdate 19th January 2021
PhysioUpdate 5th January 2021
PhysioUpdate 22nd December 2020
Industry News
9 December 2020
By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.