Immersive virtual reality eases pain and distress in people with cancer, MS and other conditions
Virtual reality (VR) interventions are effective in reducing pain and distress – particularly among people with cancer – according to researchers who conducted a pooled data analysis of the evidence.
Their study, which was funded by the Northern Ireland Health and Social Care Trust’s Business Services Organisation, is published today (17 October) in BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care. The researchers also suggest that the technology could potentially help people with conditions such as multiple sclerosis (MS), kidney disease and dementia.
They trawled research databases for studies that looked at the use and effectiveness of immersive virtual reality for aiding psychological adjustment in adults with a long-term condition. They found 31 relevant studies, published between 1993 and 2023, in which the technology had been used in patients with cancer (16), dementia (5), cardiovascular disease (4), MS (2), kidney disease (2), inflammatory bowel disease (1), and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (1).
VR could help people cope with the emotional impact of treatments
The studies ranged in size from 30 to 50 participants, with an average age of 51. Three out of four participants were women. On average, a virtual reality session lasted 20 minutes, ranging in delivery from one application to daily for a specified period.
The studies looked at environment-based and game-based immersive virtual reality interventions, designed either to relax the user ahead of medical treatment with a combination of a nature walk and mindfulness meditation, for example, or to engage them by equipping them with specific skills or behaviours to help them cope better with their condition.
Our findings suggest that VR interventions are acceptable treatments that have the potential to improve physical and psychological consequences of physical illness [William McGhee et al]
Pooling the study results showed that patients were happy to use immersive virtual reality and that it helped those with cancer, dementia, cardiovascular disease, MS and kidney disease cope better with required medical treatments and the emotional impact of their condition.
The types of virtual reality and procedures used varied widely across the included studies, and no one particular type emerged as noticeably more effective than any of the others.
But 13 of the 31 included studies were feasibility or pilot studies, and a further four were considered to have a high risk of bias. Sample sizes were often small and not many studies included a comparison group, meaning that a degree of caution is required in interpreting these findings, emphasise the researchers.
Exactly how immersive virtual realities might exert their physical and psychological effects on patients still isn’t clear, they say.
The technology might be distracting and absorbing, or alter the user’s state of mind, so reducing the subjective experience of pain and/or boosting their ability to cope with the physical and psychological impacts of their condition, suggest the researchers.
'These findings are promising in a population at risk of polypharmacy, and suggest immersive VR [virtual reality] can offer a non-pharmacological intervention that is considered acceptable by clinicians, caregivers, and patients,' they write.
William McGhee and his colleague note: 'As VR systems become progressively more accessible, immersive VR interventions may begin to offer cost benefits compared with conventional pharmacological and non-pharmacological treatments.’
Further research is needed to better understand how the technology works, if any particular type is more effective and under what circumstances, and what, if any, long term effects there might be, they note.
But the Belfast-based research team concludes: ‘Our findings suggest that VR interventions are acceptable treatments that have the potential to improve physical and psychological consequences of physical illness. There is good quality research to suggest that these VR interventions are effective in reducing pain and distress, particularly among people with cancer.
T’he article is titled Immersive virtual reality and psychological well-being in adult chronic physical illness: systematic review doi 10.1136/spcare-2023-004502.Author: Ian A McMillan